Casting the Primarchs PART 2: Who do we pick for the Warmaster?!

Avatar Jinx April 23, 202563  75 63 Likes

YouTube video

We are back and casting the last 9 of the known Primarchs and the titular Warmaster Horus. Who will Bard, Beard and Spider pick to portray these mighty champions and will you think they are completely on the money, or completely raving mad. If you haven’t already check out part one here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvutUDi7YOg&t=12s

🎥 Want even more Tabletop Tactics videos? Check out our website and sign up for On Demand! 

📱 Download our App for videos on the go, or to take part in the League! Available on Android and iOS 

🎲 Like to roll in style? Tabletop Tactics Merchandise 

🛒 For all your hobby and gaming needs, visit Tabletop Tactics’ sponsors Element Games

🛒 Or for our viewers in the US Wargames Portal

🎵 Music is licensed from their respective Artists at Premium Beat



Subscribe
Notify of
75 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paul Flory
Paul Flory
7 days ago

Terry Cruz to play all the primarchs job done ✔️

Martin Dodgson
Martin Dodgson
11 days ago

First captains!!!!

cetx
18 days ago

I think Michael Sheen for Alpharius. I’ve watched entire movies without realising a character was being played by Michael Sheen. Every time I see him, he’s somebody totally different.

SlipperyWeasel
Lodge Member
19 days ago

So who is the Emperor?

Jos de Laat
Jos de Laat
21 days ago

Bonus episode pleeeeaaasse!!

Seth McCarthy
Seth McCarthy
21 days ago

Bonus episode! Erebus, Garro, Kharn, Argel Tal, Bjorn, Malcador, Valdor, Loken, White Scar librarian (Yesugi?), Ahriman, Eisenhorn, Dante, Yarrick, Lucius.

ChazzleDazzle
ChazzleDazzle
22 days ago

Moar

Modulus
Lodge Warrior Member
23 days ago

More of these discussions would be great, please!

Also I’d like to throw out that if you were going this 30 years ago, the correct answer to the Lorgar question is Ben Kingsley.

Victoria Clarke
Victoria Clarke
23 days ago

Please please please do a 1st Captains special episode! I’d love to know your picks for The Mournival as well as Erebus!

DontpanicBanik
24 days ago

Good picks but I had Peter Mensah as Vulkan. Christopher Judge is a great pick for size and voice. Yes, please do a bonus episode

Alfie Wagstaff
Alfie Wagstaff
25 days ago

All excellent picks. But I would personally pick Adrien Brody as Mortarion.

Jeffrey Ferguson
Jeffrey Ferguson
25 days ago

Ralph Fiennes as Lorgar or Erebus

Chris
Lodge Member
Chris
25 days ago

Rhetorical question on that First Captain’s etc episode!

Clordius
Clordius
25 days ago

Definitely do the 9 next big char in the season

JUNKM0D
25 days ago

Timothée Chalamet would be in my opinion an amazing elder, I know that for Eldard they would want someone older but I bet that Chalamet would play him amazingly.

Bill
Bill
25 days ago

Deffo keen on more of these episodes- one covering other main characters and the emperor would be awesome!

Jason Meredith
26 days ago

I agree with plenty of these choices. I had batista down as vulkan for me. But I agree such an incredible actor in his own right. Has the ability to be anyone even when he’s 6ft + and built like a brick out house 😂.

Samuel Reeser
Lodge Member
Samuel Reeser
26 days ago

All the choices have been great. You definitely need to do another episode casting some of the other big name characters.

sergio espinosa
sergio espinosa
26 days ago

For the bonus episode:
Jeremy Irons as Malcador
Mark Strong as Garro
Josh Brolin as Sigismund

Richard Macpherson
Richard Macpherson
26 days ago

Want more!!!

I will die on the hill that Mark Strong would Be perfect for Lorgar.
I’m surprised that Mark didn’t get mentioned by any one.

Tristan Ryan
Lodge Member
Tristan Ryan
26 days ago

I hope all these famous actors are Warhammer fans, otherwise you guys are blowing the budget for this film big time. I really like Tom Hardy as Horus.

Richard Crichton
Richard Crichton
26 days ago

Peter Nensah as magnus is genius he was brilliant in Spartus. Also first captains you so need to do that.

Last edited 26 days ago by Richard Crichton
Ryan Ewald
Ryan Ewald
26 days ago

Daniel Day Lewis is the Emperor of Mankind.

SETH DUNAVANT
Lifetime Member
SETH DUNAVANT
26 days ago

It looks like Spider read my comment from the last vid. Ya, Brando would’ve been perfect. I d also say Clancy brown because of his ability and voice could be Magnus as its a mostly affects driven look so age wouldn’t be an issue

Ray
Ray
26 days ago

Great episode!

Dan Dryer
Dan Dryer
26 days ago

Tom Hardy as Abaddon? I need to exist in a universe where this happens.

Christopher Brown
Christopher Brown
26 days ago

Definitely do a First Captain bit. Night Lords!
Jago!

Brian Millar
26 days ago

YESSSSS FIRST CAPTAINS

Dylan Keller
Lodge Member
26 days ago

Cavill for Emperor

Ben Shepherd
Ben Shepherd
26 days ago

Remi Malek as Lorgar
Always had Mark Strong in my head as Horus
Tom Hardy as Angron
Sebastian Stan as Corax
Chris Hemsworth as Guilliman
Stone Cold Steve Austin as Ferrus.

Some of those are more serious than others.

Mathieu Lemire
Mathieu Lemire
26 days ago

Well, that was a lot of fun! YES! Please do first captains! I’m itching to find out who you would cast as Khârn! 🙂

DelinquentBunny
Lodge Member
DelinquentBunny
26 days ago

I like how Spider says Tom Hardy might be getting too old to be a primarch but picked Viggo to play the Lion. But awesome pick for Magnus though. Just inspired.

Adrian Smart
Adrian Smart
26 days ago

I appreciate the Michael Clarke Duncan shout, Joe! The man was a phenomenal actor, and taken way too soon. He’d have been an ideal Vulkan.

Liam Kofi Bright
Liam Kofi Bright
26 days ago

Loved this bonus episode please!

Elliott Cook
Elliott Cook
26 days ago

Woody Harrelson as Lucius the Eternal. But maybe he’d suit the 40K version better

Lars Tjoelker
Lars Tjoelker
26 days ago

Christopher Lee would be my pick for Malcador if he was still alive. I think id go with Ben Kingsley nou as Malcador.

Marco Gomes
Lodge Member
26 days ago

Loved this. Yes to a follow up episode for other major players. I think all your choices were on point for the most part but I can’t help thinking that Javier Bardem would make a good Mortarion🤔

JamGeo
JamGeo
26 days ago

A fun follow up would be who you think Hollywood would actually cast for the primarchs. Does Jack Black play Horus? Is Chris Pratt Sanguinius? Does Henry Cavill get snubbed somehow?

Callum Davies
Callum Davies
26 days ago

I’d love to see an episode where you cast all the female characters of the Heresy. Cyrene, Lotara, Mercedi, Euphrati, Erda, Jenetia Krole, Esher. I think there’s some really interesting, challenging roles.

But an overall major players would be great, although there are so many it’d probably need to be in at least three parts.

Joshua Thompson
26 days ago

Let’s say they choose to do something like Eisenhorn as a series, I’d like to see you cast them…… or we can just chat about it on the next game day.

As you have said in previous videos in the topic I think space marines should be fleetingly involved as what they are, monsters of humanity.

Edward Hann
Edward Hann
26 days ago

Ross Kemp stars as Horus.

Nyrad01
26 days ago

I’d enjoy another episode with other castings, a lot of good ideas here chaps!

Also I don’t know if its a bit of a curve ball, but my pick Magnus would be Chiwetel Ejiofor.

Corruption
Lifetime Member
26 days ago

For Big E you have to get Terry Gilliam to animate him like he does God in Monty Python and the Holy Grail 😀

mudcreek_miniatures
26 days ago

Jason Isaacs for Fulgrim please and thank you ☺️

A70zimm
A70zimm
26 days ago

I would love to see a first captains episode or just a key character episode as well!

stuey14
stuey14
26 days ago

Adam driver is a decent shout for corax but i cant look past keanu reeves myself …. 🤣

Corruption
Lifetime Member
26 days ago

Peter Mensah is a great pick for Magnus. Not sure about ‘The Dude’ as Big Red though, and with Beard’s intro as well as thinking the actor was possibly no longer with us I though he was going to pick Brian Blessed 😀

Lance Gulick
Lance Gulick
26 days ago

bonus episode! go go… Gary Oldman for Malcador!

Drowny
Drowny
26 days ago

I know we can get some rather lazy and clumsy writing, but…
Prediction: Beard will choose someone like Mark Heap to be Alpharius; grinning, ponder who’d care; then have a little giggle.
Rationale: so much historic mild jibing (taken in the spirit it’s intended) of our definitely, honestly, incontrovertibly first found Primarch and his legion is part of an ongoing strategy of increasingly unreliable narrative as Beard undermines Perturabo as a sleeper agent.
Evidence: (this sentence has been removed and was never here, anyway look over there at that deus ex machina…i mean…pretty cat…*vanishes*)

Justin Baker
Lodge Member
Justin Baker
26 days ago

I’d like to see their picks for the Drukhari – Vect, Lelith and Urien of course, but also the other characters we’ve lost since fifth edition.


Watch Later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later
Watch later